More than 95% of audit stakeholders surveyed by the Centre for Public Interest Audit (CPIA) have expressed satisfaction with the overall quality of public interest entity (PIE) audits for the third consecutive year.
Key takeaways:
- CPIA Audit Trust Index 2026: The third edition of the annual survey of UK audit stakeholders has been published.
- High levels of satisfaction: 96% of respondents are ‘very’ or ‘somewhat’ satisfied with the overall quality of PIE audits.
- Mixed views on AI: While 79% of respondents are satisfied with how artificial intelligence (AI) is being used in audit, some stakeholders remain less confident.
- Demand for wider assurance: 98% of respondents would like auditors to provide independent assurance over elements of corporate reporting beyond the financial statements.
The Centre for Public Interest Audit (CPIA) published its 2026 Audit Trust Index (ATI) on 13 October, confirming that satisfaction with the quality of UK PIE audits remains high. Overall, 96% of respondents said they were ‘very’ or ‘somewhat’ satisfied with audit quality.
The ATI is based on a survey of finance directors (FDs), audit committee chairs (ACCs) and UK-based equity investors. It assesses confidence in UK PIE audits and provides insight into the priorities and experiences of these stakeholder groups, as well as how their views change over time.
The findings also reveal strong support for expanding the scope of audit assurance, with 98% of respondents wanting auditors to provide more independent assurance on corporate reporting. However, views on the use of AI are less positive than in previous years. Although 79% of respondents are satisfied with how auditors use AI, 23% of ACCs report having ‘limited’ confidence, while 15% of investors have ‘limited’ or ‘no’ confidence.
ICAEW’s Audit and Assurance Faculty examines three key findings from the report and highlights relevant resources for those wishing to explore the issues further.
Audit Satisfaction Remains High
The CPIA reports that 96% of respondents are ‘very’ or ‘somewhat’ satisfied with the overall quality of audit.
The main factors contributing to satisfaction include:
- Auditors’ industry knowledge and competence.
- The quality of their communication and responsiveness.
- The usefulness of their findings.
- Their independence and objectivity.
Stakeholders also recognise the value that audits provide, with 91% expressing satisfaction with the intrinsic value of an audit.
However, the findings suggest that auditors should not become complacent. The proportion of respondents who are ‘very’ satisfied has fallen from 74% in 2025 to 48% in 2026, bringing it closer to the 2024 figure of 46%.
It is too early to establish whether this represents a longer-term trend or simply a fluctuation in the annual survey results. As the CPIA continues to build its dataset through the ATI, future editions should provide a clearer picture.
In the meantime, auditors should monitor satisfaction levels closely, particularly among FDs, who generally report lower levels of satisfaction than other stakeholder groups.
Confidence in AI Use Comes Under Pressure
Although overall satisfaction with the use of AI in audit remains relatively high at 79%, this represents a decline from 87% in 2025. The proportion of respondents who are ‘very’ satisfied has also fallen significantly, from 48% to 14%.
The reduction appears to be largely driven by declining confidence among investors, 15% of whom report having ‘limited’ or ‘no’ confidence in how auditors use AI. This highlights the importance of communicating changes in audit approaches and the role of AI clearly to stakeholders.
Despite these concerns, there is still optimism about AI’s potential benefits. More than half of respondents (54%) believe AI will improve auditors’ ability to identify control failures and misstatements.
Stakeholders see particular value in using AI for processing tasks, such as reviewing large volumes of data. However, they continue to favour human auditors when it comes to professional judgement, with ACCs expressing the strongest preference for human involvement.
The findings also highlight a shift in stakeholders’ concerns about AI-related risks. In the previous year’s survey, the main concerns were AI hallucinations and a lack of AI skills among auditors. In 2026, these have been overtaken by concerns about over-reliance on AI undermining auditors’ professional scepticism, identified by 46% of respondents, and data privacy and security risks, cited by 42%.
This change in the perceived risks of AI may help explain the decline in overall confidence in its use within audit.
Stakeholders Want Wider Assurance
The survey reveals strong agreement among stakeholders that auditors should play a broader role in providing independent assurance over corporate reporting.
The CPIA notes that this preference contrasts with the direction of some regulatory reforms, which have sought to reduce the scope of assurance requirements. For example, the government’s ongoing Modernising Corporate Reporting (MCR) consultation proposes removing certain assurance requirements for some companies.
However, stakeholders differ in the areas of corporate reporting they would most like auditors to provide assurance on. These preferences reflect the information each group considers most valuable.
ACCs and FDs place the greatest emphasis on assurance over controls reporting and regulatory disclosures. Investors, meanwhile, prioritise sustainability information, key performance indicators and leadership statements.
These differences highlight a potential tension in the MCR consultation, which aims to refocus annual reports and financial statements on the needs of investors and creditors while reducing certain reporting requirements.
The ATI also identifies gaps in stakeholders’ understanding of existing assurance arrangements. While 51% of ACCs are ‘very’ certain they understand which parts of a corporate report are covered by the external auditor’s assurance, the figures fall to 29% for investors and 31% for FDs.
This suggests that greater clarity is needed about the scope of external audit and how it relates to other forms of assurance across corporate reporting.
ICAEW will continue to monitor the CPIA’s annual Audit Trust Index and consider its findings alongside ICAEW’s ongoing response to the MCR consultation.
Info obtained here